Skip to main content

Index Funds vs. Mutual Funds

Both mutual funds and index funds are good ways to invest your money. However, they are not the same, although they seek to track the overall market. But what are the differences between the two investment vehicles? What are the similarities? Which one is the best to meet your investment objectives? If you have these questions in mind, keep reading.

What is an index fund?

An index fund seeks to follow an index as closely as possible, such as the S&P 500, Dow Jones, or the Nasdaq. The index might be a stock market index or made up of commodities or other assets. They refer to these indexes as the benchmark and aim to mimic them in their performance. 

The idea behind index funds is that no one can beat the market consistently over time. So even if you think you can pick individual stocks that will outperform the market, there’s no reason to think you’ll do better than an index fund.

An index fund is considered a passive investment, which means that once it’s selected and funded, you don’t have to make any decisions about when to buy and sell. This also means you won’t have to pay any broker commissions on high fees on a brokerage account. 

In general, index funds offer three main advantages over actively managed mutual funds. 

First, index funds usually have lower management fees than actively managed mutual funds because there is no manager to pay. There is no research team to pay either. The research is done by the people who create the indexes (like Standard & Poor’s or Russell Investments). 

The second advantage is that index funds are very tax efficient. It works like this: Most actively managed mutual funds face high turnover rates meaning that stocks may be bought and sold frequently within the fund as managers try to “time” their moves in and out of investments. 

Investors in these types of mutual funds end up paying taxes on this buying and selling activity even though they may not have participated in it themselves. There is no such buying and selling with an index fund because its portfolio remains unchanged from month to month and year to year – there are no sales taking place! 

The third advantage is that most index funds charge a lower expense ratio than actively managed mutual funds.

What is a mutual fund?

A mutual fund is similar, but it allows its investors to have more control over what is purchased and sold within the portfolio. A mutual fund investor can choose from several different types of funds, such as growth funds or value funds, which focus on buying undervalued or overvalued stocks compared to their actual worth.

Mutual funds can be either actively or passively managed. Actively managed mutual funds employ managers to pick and choose the stocks, bonds, or other investment options in their portfolios. Passive investing is a strategy that buys a predetermined basket of investment options based on a specific screening process and requires a more hands-on approach from the investor.   

Trying to find individual stocks can be very risky and time-consuming. Investors need to take the time to learn about all the different companies out there and try to understand which ones are good investments. Then, they need to wait for those companies’ stocks to go up in price to sell them for a profit.

Investing in active funds gets rid of this complication. Many people feel that mutual funds are safer than individual stocks because investors can do one less thing themselves. However, many investors also feel that mutual funds are not as safe as they should be because they don’t understand what goes into making investment decisions at these investment companies.

How are index funds and mutual funds similar?

Index funds are more different than similar, but they have a few shared traits. 

They are both ‘basket’ investments

Mutual funds and index funds are similar in that they are professionally managed collections of stocks that can represent a wide variety of investment options. As such, they offer a wide degree of diversification for investors looking to introduce that variety into their portfolio management.

They are both less risky than individual stock investments 

Individual stocks have a high degree of volatility and can be a more daunting investment for investors who don’t know how to time the market. In comparison, both index funds and mutual funds are far safer investments to make and in line with the financial goals.

They both offer variety

Depending on which index funds you are looking at, you can invest in a wider variety of international stocks and bonds. 

For example, you can find an index ETF that consists of a mix of large-cap stocks. Similarly, some mutual fund companies operate on the same principle of adding different colored eggs to the basket to reduce the risk of fluctuation. 

How are index funds and mutual funds different?

While similar, the two have a significant amount of differing points. Keep reading to find out how index funds and ETFs trade and operate differently from mutual funds.   

Investment and management style

Index funds and other mutual funds are managed by investment managers who decide when to buy or sell securities. But index funds are passively managed. They do not try to beat the market; instead, they aim to replicate the performance of a specific market index, like the S&P 500. As a result, the fund manager doesn’t actively select which stocks to buy and sell but rather follows an index, such as the S&P 500 or the Nasdaq Composite. 

Mutual funds that use active management try to beat the market by buying and selling securities in an attempt to outperform their benchmark index on an annual or quarterly basis. To achieve this, the mutual fund manager selects from various investment strategies and then makes trades accordingly. If a certain stock is performing well at any given time, he will buy more; if it performs poorly, he will sell it off. 

Expense ratios

An expense ratio is used in the same way by mutual funds and index funds. An expense ratio is an annual fee that funds charge their shareholders to operate the fund.

Because mutual funds are actively managed, investors must pay fund managers, who charge both a management fee and other types of fees. Another cost to be aware of is the sales charge known as a load that some mutual funds charge when shares are purchased or redeemed.

Index funds are passively managed, often by a computer program that tries to match the performance of a benchmark index. Securities in an index fund are bought according to a preset formula, whether that means all stocks or bonds or some combination of stocks, bonds, and real estate. In contrast, an index fund charges much lower fees and is seen as a low-cost alternative mutual fund.

Performance ability

The performance of mutual funds and index funds varies greatly. Actively managed mutual funds, especially those with an equity focus, aim to outperform the current market benchmarks. 

Professional managers and financial advisors run mutual funds. Their goal is to beat the market, and they’re judged by how well they do that. As a result, most of them try to buy stocks that will go up and sell stocks that will go down.

Index funds, however, provide more stable returns. The value of holdings in an index fund change as values of the corresponding stocks in the index change. This is a form of passive management, as opposed to actively managed funds, where the value of the holdings is adjusted frequently according to the judgment of a fund manager.

The performance of index funds is usually more stable than that of actively managed funds because they’re not subject to the risks associated with stock picking and market timing. And However, because there’s no active management, returns from index funds tend to trail behind those of actively managed funds.

Risk and volatility 

When an investor invests in an active fund, the investor trusts the fund manager to outperform their benchmark and generate higher returns. Therefore, active funds require extensive research by investors before choosing a fund. 

Index funds have a benchmark index, which is tested periodically. The risk involved in investing in an index fund is lower than investing in an active fund. 

Active funds are risky as there is no guarantee that the fund will beat its benchmark index and require extensive research. It’s not enough to look at a mutual fund’s prospectus like Vanguard, for example. Investors also have to track the net asset value (NAV), past performance, distributions, and trends to actively reduce their risk and choose the right fund for them.

Simplicity of operation

An index fund is probably the best choice for beginners because it keeps costs down and reduces investor confusion. You don’t need to be a professional and incredibly well-versed in the stock market to invest in index funds. All you have to do is pick out a relatively strong performing index, translating to lower costs too. 

Mutual funds’ complexities are reflected in their higher fees. As most mutual funds are actively managed and invest in a wider basket of stocks, they are more complex to understand and involve tracking more metrics like AUM and NAV.

Tax efficiency

Passively managed index funds offer investors lower turnover rates, fewer taxable events, and lower expense ratios than actively managed mutual funds, making them ideal for long-term investors such as retirees or college savers. 

Index funds own the same securities as their benchmark indexes, so there are no tax consequences when they trade. As a result, the only taxes you pay are the capital gains taxes on your profits when you sell your shares in the fund. 

On the other hand, mutual funds do not own all the securities their benchmarks hold. Instead, they have to constantly buy and sell securities to maintain their portfolios. They incur capital gains on those trades, which are taxed every year.

Index Funds vs. Mutual Funds: What’s right for you

Which fund is right for you depends greatly on where you are in your investment journey. An index fund is great if you’re just starting and have some extra cash lying around that you want to invest but don’t know too much about the market. 

An index fund allows investors to participate in a particular market segment, such as stocks or bonds, without picking individual companies. It is an efficient way to gain instant diversification into many different investments. For example, suppose you invest in an S&P 500 index fund instead of trying to select 50 different stocks all on your own. In that case, your investment will be diversified across 500 different companies instead of just one. You can also look at the past performance of that actual index to gauge if it’s the right one for you.

On the other hand, if you’re well experienced with the stock exchange and looking to go beyond short-term gains to make a long-term return by beating the market, the active management route is the best for you. 

If you’re better than everyone else at picking stocks or timing the market, why shouldn’t you get rich? The reason for almost everyone who tries to do this is that it’s so hard to do well consistently over time, but this is where mutual funds can help. It allows you to spread your money around through professional investment management companies, so you don’t lose everything if one investment loses money.    

So if you’re asking yourself: “which is the best for me,” try this test. Think back to your last attempt in investing and how it went. Were you able to actively stay on top of the market, or did you feel a little clueless about the share price, stock funds, and how to bring about higher returns? 

Then, you have your answer of what’s best.  


Which is better: index funds or mutual funds?

Index funds are focused on achieving market-average returns, while mutual funds try to outperform the market. Which is better for you depends on your investment strategy.

Is investing in an index fund safe?

Investing in market index funds is considered a lower risk than investing in individual stocks. This is because index funds tend to fluctuate less than individual stocks, reducing volatility and risk exposure for investors.

Is an index fund the same as a mutual fund?

An index fund is categorized as a type of mutual fund or exchange-traded fund that tracks the returns of a specific market index.