Independent fund research. Built on SEC filings.

How we research funds

Free tool

PNYAX and PNYIX: how much do they overlap?

Enter any two ETFs or mutual funds to see how much of their portfolios overlap, using each fund's latest SEC holdings report.

Bottom line

Overlap between PNYAX and PNYIX

100% of their top holdings overlap by weight, with 25 securities in common among each fund's top 25. They are largely the same portfolio — owning both adds little diversification.

Full PNYAX vs PNYIX comparison (fees, returns) →

Shared top holdings
Holding% of PNYAX% of PNYIX
United States Treasury2.39%2.39%
United States Treasury1.89%1.89%
Pimco Prv Short Term Flt III1.55%1.55%
New York City Municipal Water Finance Authority1.55%1.55%
New York State Thruway Authority1.34%1.34%
Main Street Natural Gas Inc1.27%1.27%
United States Treasury1.26%1.26%
New York State Dormitory Authority1.19%1.19%
City of New York NY1.12%1.12%
New York City Transitional Finance Authority Future Tax Secured Revenue1.08%1.08%
New York Transportation Development Corp1.07%1.07%
New York Power Authority1.06%1.06%
Town of Oyster Bay NY1.00%1.00%
New York City Transitional Finance Authority Future Tax Secured Revenue0.99%0.99%
New York City Transitional Finance Authority Future Tax Secured Revenue0.99%0.99%
New York City Municipal Water Finance Authority0.99%0.99%
New York City Municipal Water Finance Authority0.99%0.99%
Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corp Sales Tax Revenue0.95%0.95%
New York City Transitional Finance Authority Future Tax Secured Revenue0.94%0.94%
New York City Municipal Water Finance Authority0.93%0.93%
United States Treasury0.92%0.92%
New York Liberty Development Corp0.91%0.91%
New York Energy Finance Development Corp0.88%0.88%
New York City Municipal Water Finance Authority0.87%0.87%
Texas Municipal Gas Acquisition & Supply Corp V0.84%0.84%

Source: SEC Form N-PORT (periods Jun 30, 2026 / Jun 30, 2026)

Popular overlap checks

Source: SEC Form N-PORT; top-25 holdings, weight-normalized

FAQ

What is ETF overlap?
ETF overlap is the share of one fund's portfolio that is also held by another. High overlap means owning both adds little diversification — you're largely buying the same stocks twice.
How do you calculate overlap?
We take each fund's top 25 holdings from its latest SEC Form N-PORT filing, normalize the weights, and add up the smaller of the two weights for every security they share.
What is a good overlap percentage?
Below about 30% the funds are meaningfully different. Above about 70% they behave very similarly, and most investors only need one of them.
Do VOO and VTI overlap?
Heavily at the top: the largest S&P 500 companies dominate both. But VTI also holds thousands of mid- and small-cap stocks VOO doesn't, so it is broader.