Independent fund research. Built on SEC filings.

How we research funds

ETF overlap

AAPD vs MSFD overlap: 74% of top holdings shared

Bottom line

How much do AAPD and MSFD overlap?

74% of their top holdings overlap by weight. 8 securities appear in both funds' top 25, making up 54.2% of AAPD's assets and 72.0% of MSFD's. They are largely the same portfolio — owning both adds little diversification.

Updated Nov 22, 2026

Overlap at a glance

AAPDMSFD
Weight overlap (top 25)74%
Shared holdings8
Weight in shared holdings54.2%72.0%
Total positions96
Expense ratio0.96%1.02%
Holdings as ofJul 31, 2026Jul 31, 2026

Source: SEC Form N-PORT (periods Jul 31, 2026 / Jul 31, 2026)

Holdings AAPD and MSFD have in common

Holding% of AAPD% of MSFDOverlap
Dreyfus34.28%54.68%34.28%
Goldman Financial15.94%24.69%15.94%
Dreyfus1.82%9.63%1.82%
N/a1.72%-3.40%-3.40%
N/a0.99%-3.40%-3.40%
N/a-0.14%-3.40%-3.40%
N/a-0.15%-3.40%-3.40%
N/a-0.26%-3.40%-3.40%

Source: SEC Form N-PORT (periods Jul 31, 2026 / Jul 31, 2026)

Free weekly newsletter

The Fund Letter

Get fee cuts and hikes, fund closures and mergers, and one plain-English idea to make your portfolio cheaper — every week.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never sell your email.

What each fund holds that the other doesn't

Top-25 holdings that appear in only one of the two funds' top 25.

Only in AAPD

  1. Goldman Sachs Liq Es Fd A — 0.93%

Only in MSFD

None — every top holding is shared.

Asset mix

Asset typeAAPDMSFD
Cash & short-term funds53.0%89.0%
DO2.2%—

Source: SEC Form N-PORT (periods Jul 31, 2026 / Jul 31, 2026)

Check another pair

FAQ

How much do AAPD and MSFD overlap?
About 74% by weight. 8 securities appear in both funds' top 25 holdings; they make up 54.2% of AAPD's assets and 72.0% of MSFD's. They are largely the same portfolio — owning both adds little diversification.
What stocks do AAPD and MSFD have in common?
The largest shared holdings are Dreyfus, Goldman Financial, Dreyfus, N/a, N/a.
Should I own both AAPD and MSFD?
Owning both adds little diversification: most of their top holdings are the same, so most investors pick one — often the one with the lower expense ratio.
Which holds more stocks, AAPD or MSFD?
AAPD is broader, with 9 positions versus 6 for MSFD. Overlap here is measured on each fund's top 25 holdings, which carry most of the weight.

Overlap is computed from each fund's top 25 holdings in its latest SEC Form N-PORT filing, with weights normalized to the top 25; for each shared security we count the smaller of the two weights. Educational information, not investment advice.