Bottom line
SHIIX vs BUFQ: the short answer
SHIIX (Catalyst Buffered Shield Fund) and BUFQ (FT Vest Laddered Nasdaq Buffer ETF) are both mutual funds.
But SHIIX is far broader, holding 20 positions to 5 for BUFQ, so beyond the top names it adds exposure BUFQ doesn't have.
BUFQ is cheaper at 1% vs 1.31% — a difference of $31 a year per $10,000 invested.
Over one year, BUFQ returned +16.1% vs +10.9% for SHIIX (reporting dates differ).
Updated Nov 19, 2026
SHIIX vs BUFQ side by side
| SHIIX | BUFQ | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Mutual fund | ETF |
| Fund family | Mutual | First Trust |
| Category | Buffer / Defined Outcome | Buffer / Defined Outcome |
| Expense ratio | 1.31% | 1% |
| Annual cost per $10k | $131 | $100 |
| 10-yr cost on $10k (prospectus) | $2,455 | — |
| Max front load | 0% | None |
| 12b-1 fee | 0% | 0% |
| 1-yr return | +10.9% | +16.1% |
| 5-yr return (annualized) | +6.1% | — |
| 10-yr return (annualized) | +7.1% | — |
| Best quarter | +9.7% | +15.4% |
| Worst quarter | −11.5% | +0.2% |
| Net assets (fund) | $18.9M | $1.5B |
| Number of holdings | 20 | 5 |
| Portfolio turnover | % | 1% |
| Returns as of | Dec 31, 2025 | Dec 31, 2024 |
Source: SEC Form N-PORT and fund prospectuses
Year-by-year returns
| Year | SHIIX | BUFQ | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | +13.6% | +16.1% | −2.5% |
| 2023 | +14.0% | +35.8% | −21.7% |
Source: Fund prospectus bar charts
Holdings overlap
SHIIX and BUFQ share none of their top holdings.
SHIIX top 10
- Vanguard Scottsdale Funds — 34.00%
- Pgim ETF Trust — 31.27%
- Ishares Trust — 22.97%
- N/a — 4.44%
- N/a — 3.81%
- N/a — 3.51%
- N/a — 2.65%
- First American Funds Inc — 1.47%
- N/a — 0.85%
- N/a — 0.31%
BUFQ top 10
- First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 25.44%
- First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 25.35%
- First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 24.97%
- First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 24.18%
- Morgan Stanley Institutional Liquidity Funds — 0.07%
FAQ
What is the difference between SHIIX and BUFQ?
Which is cheaper, SHIIX or BUFQ?
Should I own both SHIIX and BUFQ?
Educational comparison based on public filings; not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.