Independent fund research. Built on SEC filings.

How we research funds

Fund comparison

SHIEX vs. BUFQ: which is better?

Bottom line

SHIEX vs BUFQ: the short answer

SHIEX (Catalyst Buffered Shield Fund) and BUFQ (FT Vest Laddered Nasdaq Buffer ETF) are both mutual funds.

But SHIEX is far broader, holding 20 positions to 5 for BUFQ, so beyond the top names it adds exposure BUFQ doesn't have.

BUFQ is cheaper at 1% vs 1.56% — a difference of $56 a year per $10,000 invested.

Over one year, BUFQ returned +16.1% vs +4.2% for SHIEX (reporting dates differ).

SHIEX has a front-end sales load of up to 5.75%; the other does not.

Updated Nov 19, 2026

SHIEX vs BUFQ side by side

SHIEXBUFQ
TypeMutual fundETF
Fund familyMutualFirst Trust
CategoryBuffer / Defined OutcomeBuffer / Defined Outcome
Expense ratio1.56%1%
Annual cost per $10k$156$100
10-yr cost on $10k (prospectus)$3,129—
Max front load5.75%None
12b-1 fee0.25%0%
1-yr return+4.2%+16.1%
5-yr return (annualized)+4.6%—
10-yr return (annualized)+6.2%—
Best quarter+9.7%+15.4%
Worst quarter−11.5%+0.2%
Net assets (fund)$18.9M$1.5B
Number of holdings205
Portfolio turnover%1%
Returns as ofDec 31, 2025Dec 31, 2024

Source: SEC Form N-PORT and fund prospectuses

Holdings overlap

SHIEX and BUFQ share none of their top holdings.

SHIEX top 10

  1. Vanguard Scottsdale Funds — 34.00%
  2. Pgim ETF Trust — 31.27%
  3. Ishares Trust — 22.97%
  4. N/a — 4.44%
  5. N/a — 3.81%
  6. N/a — 3.51%
  7. N/a — 2.65%
  8. First American Funds Inc — 1.47%
  9. N/a — 0.85%
  10. N/a — 0.31%

BUFQ top 10

  1. First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 25.44%
  2. First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 25.35%
  3. First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 24.97%
  4. First Trust Exchange-Traded Fund VIII — 24.18%
  5. Morgan Stanley Institutional Liquidity Funds — 0.07%

FAQ

What is the difference between SHIEX and BUFQ?
SHIEX (Catalyst Buffered Shield Fund) and BUFQ (FT Vest Laddered Nasdaq Buffer ETF) are both mutual funds. But SHIEX is far broader, holding 20 positions to 5 for BUFQ, so beyond the top names it adds exposure BUFQ doesn't have.
Which is cheaper, SHIEX or BUFQ?
BUFQ has the lower expense ratio (1%).
Should I own both SHIEX and BUFQ?
Because their portfolios differ, owning both can add diversification — check how they fit your overall allocation.

Educational comparison based on public filings; not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.