Independent fund research. Built on SEC filings.

How we research funds

Fund comparison

MSYDX vs. SMTHX: which is better?

Bottom line

MSYDX vs SMTHX: the short answer

MSYDX (NYLI MacKay Strategic Bond Fund) and SMTHX (ALPS | Smith Total Return Bond Fund) are both mutual funds.

But SMTHX is far broader, holding 1,651 positions to 725 for MSYDX, so beyond the top names it adds exposure MSYDX doesn't have.

SMTHX is cheaper at 0.59% vs 1.22% — a difference of $63 a year per $10,000 invested.

Over five years, SMTHX returned +33.0% a year vs +2.4% for MSYDX.

MSYDX has a front-end sales load of up to 4%; the other does not.

Updated Nov 19, 2026

MSYDX vs SMTHX side by side

MSYDXSMTHX
TypeMutual fundMutual fund
Fund familyMFSAmerican Funds (Capital Group)
CategoryCore / Intermediate BondCore / Intermediate Bond
Expense ratio1.22%0.59%
Annual cost per $10k$122$59
10-yr cost on $10k (prospectus)$1,838$904
Max front load4%0%
12b-1 fee0.25%0%
1-yr return+3.5%+7.0%
5-yr return (annualized)+2.4%+33.0%
10-yr return (annualized)+3.4%—
Best quarter——
Worst quarter——
Net assets (fund)$1.8B$3.5B
Number of holdings7251,651
Portfolio turnover136%131%
Returns as ofDec 31, 2025Dec 31, 2025

Source: SEC Form N-PORT and fund prospectuses

Holdings overlap

1 of MSYDX's top 25 holdings also appear in SMTHX's top 25.

Shared top holdings
HoldingMSYDXSMTHX
United States of America5.08%6.37%

Source: SEC Form N-PORT

MSYDX top 10

  1. United States of America — 8.80%
  2. United States of America — 5.08%
  3. United States of America — 1.44%
  4. NYLIM U.S. Government Liquidity Fund — 1.43%
  5. United States of America — 1.05%
  6. Invesco Govt And Agcy Lex — 0.99%
  7. J.P. Morgan Mortgage Trust — 0.48%
  8. Fhlmc — 0.45%
  9. Fnma — 0.43%
  10. STACR Trust — 0.43%

SMTHX top 10

  1. Us Treasury N/b — 6.37%
  2. Us Treasury N/b — 3.91%
  3. Us Treasury N/b — 3.46%
  4. Us Treasury N/b — 3.24%
  5. Us Treasury N/b — 2.73%
  6. Us Treasury N/b — 2.71%
  7. Us Treasury N/b — 2.56%
  8. Us Treasury N/b — 2.30%
  9. Us Treasury N/b — 1.86%
  10. Us Treasury N/b — 1.71%

FAQ

What is the difference between MSYDX and SMTHX?
MSYDX (NYLI MacKay Strategic Bond Fund) and SMTHX (ALPS | Smith Total Return Bond Fund) are both mutual funds. But SMTHX is far broader, holding 1,651 positions to 725 for MSYDX, so beyond the top names it adds exposure MSYDX doesn't have.
Which is cheaper, MSYDX or SMTHX?
SMTHX has the lower expense ratio (0.59%).
Should I own both MSYDX and SMTHX?
Because their portfolios differ, owning both can add diversification — check how they fit your overall allocation.

Educational comparison based on public filings; not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.