Bottom line
MSXAX vs FXAIX: the short answer
MSXAX (NYLI S&P 500 Index Fund) and FXAIX (Fidelity 500 Index Fund) are both mutual funds.
FXAIX is cheaper at 0.015% vs 0.51% — a difference of $50 a year per $10,000 invested.
Over five years, FXAIX returned +14.4% a year vs +13.5% for MSXAX (reporting dates differ).
MSXAX has a front-end sales load of up to 1.5%; the other does not.
Updated Nov 19, 2026
MSXAX vs FXAIX side by side
| MSXAX | FXAIX | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Mutual fund | Mutual fund |
| Fund family | New York Life Investments | Fidelity |
| Category | S&P 500 Index | S&P 500 Index |
| Expense ratio | 0.51% | 0.015% |
| Annual cost per $10k | $51 | $1.5 |
| 10-yr cost on $10k (prospectus) | $781 | $19 |
| Max front load | 1.5% | — |
| 12b-1 fee | 0.25% | 0% |
| 1-yr return | +15.5% | +17.9% |
| 5-yr return (annualized) | +13.5% | +14.4% |
| 10-yr return (annualized) | +13.9% | +14.8% |
| Best quarter | — | +20.5% |
| Worst quarter | — | −19.6% |
| Net assets (fund) | $2.1B | $832.2B |
| Number of holdings | 509 | 507 |
| Portfolio turnover | 1% | 3% |
| Returns as of | Dec 31, 2025 | Apr 30, 2026 |
Source: SEC Form N-PORT and fund prospectuses
Holdings overlap
22 of MSXAX's top 25 holdings also appear in FXAIX's top 25.
| Holding | MSXAX | FXAIX |
|---|---|---|
| NVIDIA Corp. | 7.47% | 7.89% |
| Apple, Inc. | 6.97% | 7.05% |
| Microsoft Corp. | 5.30% | 5.14% |
| Amazon.com, Inc. | 4.08% | 4.07% |
| Alphabet, Inc. | 3.21% | 3.41% |
| Broadcom, Inc. | 2.83% | 3.26% |
| Alphabet, Inc. | 2.59% | 2.71% |
| Meta Platforms, Inc. | 1.88% | 2.13% |
| JPMorgan Chase & Co. | 1.45% | 1.24% |
| Berkshire Hathaway, Inc. | 1.44% | 1.34% |
| Micron Technology, Inc. | 1.43% | 1.68% |
| Eli Lilly & Co. | 1.40% | 1.35% |
| Tesla, Inc. | 1.35% | 1.88% |
| Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. | 1.19% | 1.29% |
| Johnson & Johnson | 0.95% | 0.84% |
Source: SEC Form N-PORT
MSXAX top 10
- NVIDIA Corp. — 7.47%
- Apple, Inc. — 6.97%
- Microsoft Corp. — 5.30%
- Amazon.com, Inc. — 4.08%
- Alphabet, Inc. — 3.21%
- Broadcom, Inc. — 2.83%
- Alphabet, Inc. — 2.59%
- Meta Platforms, Inc. — 1.88%
- JPMorgan Chase & Co. — 1.45%
- Berkshire Hathaway, Inc. — 1.44%
FXAIX top 10
- Nvidia Corp — 7.89%
- Apple Inc — 7.05%
- Microsoft Corp — 5.14%
- Amazon.com Inc — 4.07%
- Alphabet Inc — 3.41%
- Broadcom Inc — 3.26%
- Alphabet Inc — 2.71%
- Meta Platforms Inc — 2.13%
- Tesla Inc — 1.88%
- Micron Technology Inc — 1.68%
FAQ
What is the difference between MSXAX and FXAIX?
Which is cheaper, MSXAX or FXAIX?
Should I own both MSXAX and FXAIX?
Educational comparison based on public filings; not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.