Independent fund research. Built on SEC filings.

How we research funds

Fund comparison

MSTIX vs. MTFGX: which is better?

Bottom line

MSTIX vs MTFGX: the short answer

MSTIX (NYLI MacKay Short Term Muni Fund) and MTFGX (NYLI MacKay Strategic Muni Allocation Fund) are both mutual funds.

But MTFGX is far broader, holding 1,423 positions to 439 for MSTIX, so beyond the top names it adds exposure MSTIX doesn't have.

MSTIX is cheaper at 0.4% vs 0.49% — a difference of $9.00 a year per $10,000 invested.

Over five years, MTFGX returned +1.7% a year vs +1.7% for MSTIX.

Updated Nov 19, 2026

MSTIX vs MTFGX side by side

MSTIXMTFGX
TypeMutual fundMutual fund
Fund familyNew York Life InvestmentsNew York Life Investments
CategoryMunicipal BondAllocation / Balanced
Expense ratio0.4%0.49%
Annual cost per $10k$40$49
10-yr cost on $10k (prospectus)$528$616
Max front load0%0%
12b-1 fee0%0%
1-yr return+4.7%+5.0%
5-yr return (annualized)+1.7%+1.7%
10-yr return (annualized)+1.7%—
Best quarter+3.4%+5.7%
Worst quarter−2.7%−5.4%
Net assets (fund)$1.4B$2.7B
Number of holdings4391,423
Portfolio turnover76%47%
Returns as ofDec 31, 2025Dec 31, 2025

Source: SEC Form N-PORT and fund prospectuses

Year-by-year returns

YearMSTIXMTFGXDifference
2025+4.7%+5.0%−0.3%
2024+2.7%+2.3%+0.4%
2023+4.0%+6.2%−2.3%
2022−3.3%−6.8%+3.6%
2021+0.4%+2.6%−2.2%
2020+2.6%+4.7%−2.2%

Source: Fund prospectus bar charts

Holdings overlap

4 of MSTIX's top 25 holdings also appear in MTFGX's top 25.

Shared top holdings
HoldingMSTIXMTFGX
San Antonio Water System1.83%0.41%
Arkansas Development Finance Authority1.24%0.49%
BNY Dreyfus Government Cash Management0.94%0.65%
Main Street Natural Gas, Inc.0.91%0.77%

Source: SEC Form N-PORT

MSTIX top 10

  1. City of New York NY — 2.27%
  2. Southeast Energy Authority A Cooperative District — 1.92%
  3. San Antonio Water System — 1.83%
  4. Pennsylvania Economic Development Financing Authority — 1.49%
  5. New Hampshire Business Finance Authority — 1.32%
  6. Arkansas Development Finance Authority — 1.24%
  7. Matching Fund Special Purpose Securitization Corp. — 1.13%
  8. BlackRock Municipal 2030 Target Term Trust — 0.99%
  9. Main Street Energy, Inc. — 0.99%
  10. New York Energy Finance Development Corp. — 0.97%

MTFGX top 10

  1. Puerto Rico Sales Tax Financing Corp. — 0.99%
  2. Chicago Board of Education Dedicated Capital Improvement Tax — 0.86%
  3. Main Street Natural Gas, Inc. — 0.77%
  4. BNY Dreyfus Government Cash Management — 0.65%
  5. Metropolitan Transportation Authority — 0.59%
  6. Minnesota Municipal Gas Agency — 0.56%
  7. Kentucky Public Energy Authority — 0.56%
  8. Black Belt Energy Gas District — 0.52%
  9. Commonwealth of Puerto Rico — 0.51%
  10. Development Authority of Burke County (The) — 0.49%

FAQ

What is the difference between MSTIX and MTFGX?
MSTIX (NYLI MacKay Short Term Muni Fund) and MTFGX (NYLI MacKay Strategic Muni Allocation Fund) are both mutual funds. But MTFGX is far broader, holding 1,423 positions to 439 for MSTIX, so beyond the top names it adds exposure MSTIX doesn't have.
Which is cheaper, MSTIX or MTFGX?
MSTIX has the lower expense ratio (0.4%).
Should I own both MSTIX and MTFGX?
Because their portfolios differ, owning both can add diversification — check how they fit your overall allocation.

Educational comparison based on public filings; not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.