Independent fund research. Built on SEC filings.

How we research funds

Fund comparison

FXD vs. XLY: which is better?

Bottom line

FXD vs XLY: the short answer

FXD (First Trust Consumer Discretionary AlphaDEX Fund) and XLY (State Street(R) Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR(R) ETF) are both etfs.

But FXD is far broader, holding 114 positions to 51 for XLY, so beyond the top names it adds exposure XLY doesn't have.

XLY is cheaper at 0.08% vs 0.6% — a difference of $52 a year per $10,000 invested.

Over five years, XLY returned +9.1% a year vs +8.2% for FXD (reporting dates differ).

Updated Nov 19, 2026

FXD vs XLY side by side

FXDXLY
TypeETFETF
Fund familyFirst TrustSPDR (State Street)
CategoryConsumer SectorConsumer Sector
Expense ratio0.6%0.08%
Annual cost per $10k$60$8
10-yr cost on $10k (prospectus)—$103
Max front loadNoneNone
12b-1 fee0%0.02%
1-yr return+10.7%+7.4%
5-yr return (annualized)+8.2%+9.1%
10-yr return (annualized)+7.0%+13.0%
Best quarter+38.9%+30.6%
Worst quarter−40.3%−25.5%
Net assets (fund)$269.2M$22.6B
Number of holdings11451
Portfolio turnover68%1%
Returns as ofDec 31, 2024Dec 31, 2025

Source: SEC Form N-PORT and fund prospectuses

Year-by-year returns

YearFXDXLYDifference
2024+10.7%+26.5%−15.7%
2023+23.3%+39.6%−16.4%
2022−21.5%−36.2%+14.8%
2021+22.7%+27.8%−5.1%
2020+12.9%+29.6%−16.7%
2019+24.2%+28.4%−4.3%
2018−11.4%+1.7%−13.1%
2017+19.7%+22.8%−3.0%
2016+5.1%+5.9%−0.8%

Source: Fund prospectus bar charts

Holdings overlap

1 of FXD's top 25 holdings also appear in XLY's top 25.

Shared top holdings
HoldingFXDXLY
General Motors Company1.38%1.73%

Source: SEC Form N-PORT

FXD top 10

  1. Fox Corp — 1.67%
  2. Dillard's Inc — 1.66%
  3. Mattel Inc — 1.63%
  4. Lyft Inc — 1.62%
  5. Gap Inc (the) — 1.61%
  6. Sharkninja Inc — 1.59%
  7. Lithia Motors Inc — 1.59%
  8. Macy's Inc — 1.58%
  9. Lululemon Athletica Inc — 1.56%
  10. Sirius Xm Holdings Inc — 1.50%

XLY top 10

  1. Amazon.com Inc — 22.22%
  2. Tesla Inc — 19.64%
  3. Home Depot Inc/The — 5.83%
  4. McDonald's Corp — 4.15%
  5. TJX Cos Inc/The — 3.92%
  6. Booking Holdings Inc — 3.44%
  7. Lowe's Cos Inc — 3.07%
  8. Starbucks Corp — 2.90%
  9. Marriott International Inc/MD — 2.02%
  10. Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd — 1.97%

FAQ

What is the difference between FXD and XLY?
FXD (First Trust Consumer Discretionary AlphaDEX Fund) and XLY (State Street(R) Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR(R) ETF) are both etfs. But FXD is far broader, holding 114 positions to 51 for XLY, so beyond the top names it adds exposure XLY doesn't have.
Which is cheaper, FXD or XLY?
XLY has the lower expense ratio (0.08%).
Should I own both FXD and XLY?
Because their portfolios differ, owning both can add diversification — check how they fit your overall allocation.

Educational comparison based on public filings; not investment advice. Past performance does not guarantee future results.